sports-culture-and-community-impact
Phil Mickelson’s Most Notable Comebacks on the Pga Tour
Table of Contents
Phil Mickelson’s professional golf career spans more than three decades, and few players have demonstrated the ability to rise from disappointment to triumph as often as the left-hander. His comebacks are not confined to a single tournament turnaround; rather, they encompass defying age, overcoming personal hardships, and silencing critics who wrote him off. From his first major victory at the 2004 Masters to his historic win at the 2021 PGA Championship at age 50, these moments define a career built on persistence and an unshakable belief in his own ability. Mickelson’s journey is a masterclass in resilience, showing that talent alone is never enough — it takes constant reinvention, mental toughness, and a willingness to embrace failure as fuel for future success.
Early Career: The Weight of "Best Player Never to Win a Major"
In the late 1990s and early 2000s, Mickelson was already a multiple-time winner on the PGA Tour but carried the label of "best player never to win a major." He finished runner-up in three U.S. Opens — 1999 at Pinehurst, 2002 at Bethpage Black, and 2004 at Shinnecock Hills — and came close at the Masters, but each near-miss added pressure. Critics questioned his course management, his aggressive style, and his ability to close when it mattered most. After a disappointing 2003 season in which he failed to win a major and slipped in the world rankings, many wondered whether he would ever break through. The narrative had become so entrenched that even his biggest supporters began to doubt.
Instead of folding, Mickelson re-dedicated himself to physical conditioning and short-game precision. He worked with swing coach Rick Smith and putter specialist Dave Pelz to refine his wedge play and putting stroke. He also hired a fitness trainer to improve his flexibility and stamina. These changes were not overnight fixes but incremental improvements that laid the foundation for a comeback that would change his legacy. The 2003 season, while statistically solid, had been a mental crucible; Mickelson later described it as a period where he learned to "embrace the struggle rather than fight it." That mindset shift proved crucial.
"I had to stop trying to prove everyone wrong and start proving myself right," Mickelson said in a 2014 interview. "The doubters were a motivation, but the real work was inside my head."
The 2004 Masters: Ending the Major Drought
The 2004 Masters stands as the defining moment of Mickelson's early career — a comeback from the depths of a decade of major-championship frustration. He arrived at Augusta National with renewed confidence after a strong start to the 2004 season that included a win at the Bob Hope Chrysler Classic. On the final day, he trailed by one shot entering the back nine. A birdie on the 16th hole — a precise 9-iron to 12 feet — gave him a share of the lead, but it was his 18-foot birdie putt on the 72nd hole that sealed the victory. Mickelson leaped into the air, his arms raised in pure joy, and the roar from the gallery became one of the most iconic sounds in golf history.
That putt ended a streak of 42 major starts without a win and validated his comeback from the depths of near-misses. The victory proved that resilience, not just raw talent, could carry a player to the pinnacle of the sport. Mickelson's final-round 69 was a study in controlled aggression — he attacked the pins when necessary but showed patience on the par-5s. The emotion he displayed after the putt was raw and genuine, a stark contrast to the stoic image of many champions.
"I still can't believe it," Mickelson said after the round. "All the hard work, all the disappointment — it was all worth it for this moment."
That win (source: PGA Tour story on 2004 Masters) was not just a victory; it was a psychological breakthrough that allowed him to compete for major titles with far less mental baggage for the rest of his career. It also changed the way the golf world viewed him — no longer the talented underachiever, but a true champion capable of closing under the brightest lights.
2010 Masters: Another Comeback After Personal Turmoil
Six years after his first major, Mickelson faced perhaps his greatest off-course challenge. His wife, Amy, was diagnosed with breast cancer in May 2009, and shortly after, his mother was also diagnosed with the same disease. Mickelson immediately took time away from the tour to support his family, and his return to competitive golf was uncertain. He played sporadically through the remainder of 2009, his mind never fully on the game. At the 2010 Masters, he arrived as a fan favorite but not a clear favorite to win — the emotional toll of the past year was apparent, and many wondered if he could compartmentalize his personal struggles long enough to compete.
Through the first three rounds, he played steady golf, carding rounds of 67, 71, and 67 to put himself within striking distance. On Sunday, he produced a masterclass in pressure putting. The defining moment came on the 13th hole — a spectacular shot from the pine straw under the trees. With no clear line to the green, Mickelson unleashed a 6-iron that curled around the branches, landed softly, and settled within four feet of the cup. He made the eagle putt, assuming a lead he never relinquished. He finished with a 67 to win his third green jacket, and the emotional embrace with his family on the 18th green was a poignant reminder that comebacks are not just about golf — they are about life.
This victory was widely regarded as the most meaningful of his career, as it symbolized his resilience off the course as much as on it. (Read more in ESPN's coverage of the 2010 Masters). The win also carried extra weight because it showed that Mickelson could channel deep personal pain into professional excellence — a lesson that resonated far beyond the golf world.
2013 Open Championship: Finally Winning the Claret Jug
One of the persistent notes in Mickelson's career was his inability to win The Open Championship. The links game seemed to elude him — his aggressive, high-ball flight was ill-suited to the low, running shots required on most British courses. He had come close — a second-place finish at Royal St. George's in 2011 and a tie for third in 2004 — but each near-miss reinforced the narrative that he could not conquer the seaside challenges. After a disappointing showing at the 2013 U.S. Open, where he finished tied for 13th, he traveled to Muirfield with modest expectations.
A first-round 69 kept him in contention, but it was a stunning third-round 64, highlighted by a 28-foot birdie putt on the 18th, that thrust him into the lead. That round was a masterful display of links golf — he used a 3-wood off the tee on many holes to keep the ball below the wind, and his irons were flighted with precision. On a rainy final day, he held off Henrik Stenson and Ian Poulter with a clutch birdie on the 71st hole, a 10-foot putt that broke sharply left to right. The victory made him just the sixth player at the time to complete the career Grand Slam, joining an elite club that included Gene Sarazen, Ben Hogan, Gary Player, Jack Nicklaus, and Tiger Woods.
That comeback was notable not only for the tournament victory but also for the way Mickelson had reinvented his short game specifically for links conditions. He worked with a team of coaches, including short-game guru Dave Pelz, to perfect the low, running shots that Muirfield demanded. He also practiced extensively on a seaside practice facility in Scotland before the championship. The ability to adapt his style to the environment showed that hard work and humility can overcome even the most stubborn weaknesses. (For more on his career Grand Slam, see BBC Sport’s report on the 2013 Open).
Mid-Career Slump and 2018–2019 Resurgence
After winning the Open Championship, Mickelson entered a period of relative decline. From 2014 to 2017, he won only once on the PGA Tour — a victory at the 2017 WGC-Mexico Championship — and his world ranking slipped outside the top 20. Many analysts began to talk about the end of his competitive era. His driving accuracy declined, and his putting became less reliable. At the 2017 Masters, he finished tied for 22nd, and at the U.S. Open that year, he missed the cut. The murmurings that he should focus on the PGA Tour Champions grew louder.
But in early 2018, Mickelson surprised the golf world by winning the WGC-Mexico Championship for a second time, defeating Justin Thomas in a playoff. That victory was followed by a win at the AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am in 2019, where he shot a final-round 65 to overtake a stacked leaderboard. Each time, he pointed to changes in his diet and exercise routine, as well as a renewed focus on the mental side of the game. He adopted a stricter diet that cut out sugar and processed foods, and he began working with a new fitness coach to improve his core strength. These comebacks, while not as dramatic as his major wins, proved that he could still compete with players half his age — and that his hunger for victory had not diminished.
His performance at the 2018 U.S. Open at Shinnecock Hills also turned heads — he shot a final-round 69 to finish in a tie for sixth, his best result in that major since 2013. That week, his resilience was evident in his refusal to let bad breaks derail his round, a maturity he credited to years of experience. "I've learned that patience isn't just waiting — it's staying positive when the momentum is against you," he told reporters after the round. The 2018–19 resurgence reminded the golf world that Mickelson’s competitive fire was far from extinguished.
The 2021 PGA Championship: The Greatest Comeback of All
As Mickelson approached his 50th birthday in 2020, the prevailing narrative was that he would soon fade to the PGA Tour Champions. Few seriously considered him a contender at major championships. He had not won on the PGA Tour since 2019, and his putting had become erratic — he ranked outside the top 150 in strokes gained putting in 2020. At the 2021 PGA Championship at Kiawah Island's Ocean Course, Mickelson played with a freedom and creativity that recalled his prime. He opened with a 70 and then shot 69 to sit near the lead. A third-round 68, highlighted by a series of clutch par saves, gave him a one-shot lead over Brooks Koepka.
Most observers expected a collapse. Mickelson had not led a major after 54 holes since the 2014 U.S. Open, where he had faltered on Sunday. But on a blustery final day at the Ocean Course, he battled nerves, a charging Brooks Koepka, and the hardest conditions of the week. Despite bogeys on two of the first four holes, he never panicked. He saved par from bunkers on the 5th and 8th holes, holed critical putts from 10 feet on the back nine, and struck a 7-iron into the 17th green that set up a birdie and a two-shot lead. When he tapped in for par on the 18th, he became the oldest winner of a major championship in history — 50 years, 11 months, and 7 days old.
"I believed that I could do it, but honestly, I didn't think the stars would align like this," Mickelson said after the win. "This one feels incredibly special because of all the doubt."
The victory was hailed as one of the greatest comebacks in the history of the sport — not just because of his age, but because of the years of struggle that preceded it. He had missed cuts, struggled with his swing, and faced criticism for a move to LIV Golf that was already brewing behind the scenes. Yet on that Sunday at Kiawah, he summoned a round of pure grit. That win earned him a place in the PGA Tour's history books (PGA Tour report on the 2021 PGA Championship) and inspired a generation of older players to believe that age is not a barrier to greatness.
Overcoming Injury and Physical Setbacks
Mickelson’s comebacks have not been limited to mental resilience alone. In 2015, he suffered a sports hernia that required surgery and months of rehabilitation. The injury affected his swing and limited his practice time, but he returned to the tour earlier than expected and finished tied for second at the 2015 Open Championship, just one stroke behind Zach Johnson. That performance, which included a final-round 65 on the Old Course at St. Andrews, was a testament to his ability to adapt his swing to compensate for physical limitations.
In the years that followed, Mickelson dealt with psoriatic arthritis, a condition that caused joint pain and swelling. He modified his practice routines and took medication to manage the symptoms, yet he continued to compete at the highest level. In 2022, after a move to LIV Golf, he faced intense media scrutiny and personal backlash over controversial comments, yet he still posted top-10s in several LIV events and shot a 59 in a practice round — a sign that the competitive fire had not dimmed. His ability to reinvent his body and his game in his 40s and 50s sets him apart from almost every player in history. (Learn more about his health battles in Golf.com’s feature on Mickelson’s arthritis).
Near-Misses That Showed Resilience
While Mickelson’s wins define his career, his near-misses also illustrate his comeback spirit. The 2009 U.S. Open at Bethpage Black was one of the most heart-wrenching: he held the lead through three rounds but stumbled on Sunday, eventually finishing tied for second. Instead of falling apart, he used that disappointment as motivation for his 2010 Masters victory. Similarly, his runner-up finish at the 2011 Open Championship at Royal St. George’s — where he birdied the 72nd hole but lost by a stroke — showed his refusal to give up until the final putt. In 2016 at the Open Championship, he tied for second again, and in 2018 at the U.S. Open, he posted a top-6 finish when few expected him to contend.
These performances, while not victories, reinforced his reputation as a player who could bounce back from defeat. They also kept him in the conversation as a threat at majors, paving the way for the 2021 triumph. Mickelson himself has said that the near-misses taught him more than the wins ever did, because they forced him to analyze his weaknesses and improve. The resilience shown in those losses is as much a part of his legacy as the trophies on his mantle.
Legacy of Resilience
Phil Mickelson’s career is a case study in the power of persistence. From the early doubts about his major-championship ability, to the personal tragedies that could have derailed him, to the age-defying triumph at Kiawah Island, he has repeatedly shown that comebacks are possible when talent is matched with relentless work ethic and an optimistic mindset. His six major championships and 45 PGA Tour victories are a testament to a man who never quit, even when everyone else thought he should. For young golfers and sports fans alike, Mickelson’s most notable comebacks provide a blueprint for handling adversity: stay patient, keep learning, adapt to changing circumstances, and never stop believing that the next victory is always possible.
His impact extends beyond the results. Mickelson has inspired countless players — both amateur and professional — to embrace a growth mindset. He has shown that age is not a limitation, that personal hardship can be channeled into greatness, and that even the most stubborn weaknesses can be overcome with dedication. In an era of robotic consistency, Mickelson’s willingness to take risks, fail publicly, and come back stronger makes him one of the most compelling figures in sports history. (For a full statistical overview of Mickelson's career, see his official PGA Tour profile.)